Thursday, January 19, 2006

Open It Up

In an effort to keep my New Year’s resolution of not driving my readers berserk with relentless diatribes about George W. Bush’s misbegotten Iraq War and his insensitive approach to Social Security, this will be the first in a series of postings on energy and the environment. I consider myself an environmentalist in good standing as, I’m certain, do most of those who temporarily perch on this site. With that guarantee on the table, I’m going to slam both the federal government and the environmentalists.

As for the federal government, I’ve been doing little but calling the president such well earned appellations as the Used Car Salesman in Chief and Bubble Boy for the past year and a half mostly for his failed adventure in Iraq which had its genesis in our profligate national demand for oil. With my anti administration bona fides established, I’m going to begin by goring the goody goodies. As many of my friends will find this an uncomfortable detour from my usual way, I hope that you will read to the end where I will attempt to tie it all together in a rational and moderate fashion.

I’m for opening up the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge (ANWR) for drilling. There are environmental risks to drilling in the refuge, but, as has been shown virtually next door in the Prudhoe Bay oil field, it is possible for oil exploration, drilling, and extraction to take place without the sky falling. Given the backgrounds of many of my readers, it is certain they have been bombarded with the horror tomes created by the many environmental groups. These publications are uniformly doomsday documents showing every possible disastrous possibility as a near certainty and labeling anyone who would consider opening up the refuge as an eco criminal. Dear reader, you have every right to be concerned.

The arguments against drilling fall into a few narrow categories: it will irreparably damage the fragile environment and the resident and visiting wildlife; it will not help the treasury of the federal government but will enrich the rapacious oil companies; and it won’t improve our precarious energy situation as the total production amounts to but a drop in the bucket of our usage. These are difficult arguments to refute since proving negatives and determining whether glasses are half full or empty lies in the eyes of those beholding the vessels.

It is possible that despite the technological advances made since Prudhoe Bay was opened that spills could occur. In fact, spills occur on a daily basis in the field. What is never reported by these doom sayers is that the spills are almost all very small, that they are cleaned up quickly with almost no damage to the environment, and that systematic efforts are undertaken to learn from each event to assure that recurrence is minimized. Rarely, if ever, stated by opponents of Arctic drilling is the fact that all these Alaskan fields were discovered when natural oil seepage was observed by early explorers.

I’ll stipulate right at the top that the refuge is fragile and its wildlife is sensitive. But the arguments being raised are the same as those used by opponents of Prudhoe Bay next door to the ANWR which has very similar geography and wildlife. We were warned that the caribou were sure to be adversely affected in that ecosystem, but the animals have thrived despite the horrible warnings by these same environmental groups. And it is likely that opening up the refuge will produce a similar result.

The gravest danger to the ANWR environment has to do with energy consumption by the modern world and the shift away from oil may be too late as it is. But to turn the environmentalists’ favorite argument back on them, extracting ANWR deposits, which they claim are so small, will do little additional harm to the flora and fauna. They beat us about the head and shoulders saying that the recoverable crude oil and gas in the refuge is but a drop in the bucket of America’s humongous demand, they must believe that even if I don’t.

While I’m no great believer in the truthfulness of federal agencies, two groups, The U.S. Geologic Survey (USGS) and the Energy Information Agency (EIA) have always met my standard of organizations that put out useful and truthful information and data.

The best and latest estimate of the USGS is that at $24.00 per barrel, about market price in 2000, there was a 95% chance of finding 1.9 billion barrels of recoverable oil. Since the Iraq War, as you rediscover every time you fill up your gas tank, the price of oil has skyrocketed. In addition with the emergence of major new consumers such as China and India, it is inconceivable that the price of extraction will fall back to anywhere near the inflation adjusted price of $24.00. In the 2000 assessment, USGS estimated a 50% chance of finding 5.3 billion barrels. I won’t bore you with further upward estimates, but will settle for this argument on not less than 3 billion barrels of recoverable oil which has been making the rounds in popular print. The media has also settled on this being something above six months of total usage by the country. This has been seized upon by opponents of opening up the refuge as simply a drop in the bucket.

Looking at the refuge as supplying our total petroleum needs for something over half a year is not the way to proceed. No single source can be evaluated in those terms. The better way is state that the refuge could produce more than 6% of daily – and, of course, annual – petroleum consumption as specified by the EIA and this would go on for several decades. This in itself would be no justification for going ahead with the program, but we as a people are beginning to see what geologists and economists have been telling us for many years and what American presidents – with the exception of the present incumbent - have been aware of since 1973 when the Arab Oil Embargo was thrust upon us.

The size of the ANWR oil footprint on the reserve is about 2,000 acres, a sizeable chunk of land, but the size of the ANWR itself is almost nine million acres. The oil would be shipped the few miles west to the existing pipeline that carries Alaskan oil from Prudhoe Bay, thus minimizing the physical impact still further.

It is now known to thinking Americans and becoming apparent to millions of ordinary people who have never considered the underlying basis for our modern society that we are now transitioning to an economy and society that will be based primarily on forms of energy other than petroleum (and natural gas). The cost of putting the feedbag on old Paint, our trusty SUV, and for heating out 5,000 sq ft. home forty miles from the general store is staggering to us. Naturally, we can shoot – or scrap – old Paint in the short term from today until it stops on its own in about a decade, but it’s not going to be easy to deal with the tens of thousands of McMansions we’ve built in the exurbs over the past quarter century.

We are at the early stages of conserving energy with a dedication unknown since W.W.II. Soon we’ll be driving smaller more energy efficient vehicles and we’ll insulate like we’ve never done, but that will help only slightly. We have to have additional sources of energy, but even this isn’t easy. My friends in Massachusetts are biting their nails over the need for more and cheaper energy and the environmental degradation likely to be caused by a proposed wind farm for the middle of Nantucket Sound.

NIMBY, not in my backyard, is very real. Every new source of energy from solar and wind farms to nuclear plants or liquefied natural gas ports provides hope and fear. It isn’t easy to site a major energy facility. I know; I spent years working on siting the Yucca Mountain nuclear waste repository in Nevada. I’ve been retired for well over a decade, and the last I heard, Senator Reid isn’t planning on turning the first symbolic shovel in the project any time soon.

What does all this have to do with the ANWR? We are suffering from the dramatic increase in the price of oil, and we are merely in the first stages of making the extraordinarily painful transition to heavy duty energy conservation and to alternative forms of energy. This will be among the most economically agonizing processes ever undertaken by the American people, and, as is always the case, the most suffering will be by those least able to defend themselves, the poor and those on fixed incomes.

If we open the reserve to oil extraction, the world price of petroleum will be impacted, even if only slightly. While this price will not be enough to slow conservation and the shift to other forms of energy it will assist the government in aiding the helpless.

There are two more canards about this project that must be addressed. First, only the oil companies will be enriched while the government gets a pittance from the leases. The leases can be written in a manner than reflects market conditions. The oil companies will be the organizations taking the great risks and they should be rewarded accordingly, especially if we want to feed old Paint until we can afford a battery driven car. The government can defend the rights of the nation by assuring that the contracts cover contingencies such as even sharper rises in the world price of oil.

Second, an even more important argument thrown around by the opponents of opening up the ANWR is that the oil may even be sold to other nations and not kept in the United States. This is truly a bit of flimflam. Oil is fungible and flows to price. If oil from the ANWR is sold on the open market it will flow to where it can be sold and used most economically. If it is cheaper for the oil in the reserve to flow to China, New York’s supply will flow from Saudi Arabia or wherever it is most effective.

Naturally, if there is a crisis brought on by war or political crisis, the leases can be written to assure that the oil from the ANWR is reserved for this country.

If you’re still with me, I still claim to be a moderate and I hope that you believe it. Soon I’ll write about the Bush administration which I consider the least sensitive ever in terms of energy and the environment. Right now, I’m in need of Happy Hour.

Blog on!

Wild Bill

Tuesday, January 17, 2006

Walk On

Despite the usual two trips to the store, our journey to good health, great longevity and a dementia free future continues. Two trips? Surely you know the Wild Bill two trip rule? ` Anything bought in a store requires two trips to straighten out the situation.’ That one of our pedometers was defective should surprise no one outside of the Bush family which still marvels at discovering such up to date technology as scanners at the check out station.

I’ll begin with a story of failure. Last Sunday (1/15/06) was a terribly blustery day with wind gusts whipping at up to forty miles per hour. It was also the day that our gridiron heroes would be tested. Barbara and I are very fortunate for having lived in the home territories of two of the most successful franchises of the National Football League, the Washington Redskins and the New England Patriots. Even more fortuitous, the teams are in opposite conferences so we can root for them with almost no fear of a conflict of interest until the very end.

So Sunday was a day of great anticipation in this house as both of our favorites would be appearing in the post season playoffs on the same day. Naturally anticipation trumped realization and both teams are resting comfortably after being dispatched to their home TVs for the rest of the championship round.

The Redskins played courageously and well and most of the breaks went their way. Unfortunately for the local fanatics, the team was simply not good enough to defeat a very fine Seattle team. On the other hand, the Patriots appeared to us to be the superior outfit but lost to Denver at Mile High Stadium in a complete meltdown in the fourth quarter. The pre game hype was designed to show that playing at altitude would not hinder the New England contingent. Even the vaunted Boston medical community shared almost believable expertise saying that the thin air would not be a factor.

Back to the scrub line you overeducated morons! The altitude caused the slaughter. The play through three quarters was fairly even, but the lack of oxygen showed up in the final stanza and the wheels fell off the Patriot’s chariot.

In the army shortly after the Korean War, I was stationed at near sea level and was sent to Colorado for extremely physically demanding training. For several days while in very fine condition and near my prime, I found the training to be extraordinarily taxing and performed nowhere near my best. There is no way that a visiting team can perform anywhere near its best in Denver. That home field provides the greatest advantage in the nation.

That said, you can see why we were couch potatoes for the day. The goal of ten thousand steps was failed by more than half, and, of course, our consumption of junk food and alcohol must be excused as factors beyond the control of mortals.

Now for the facts for the rest of you; taking ten thousand steps a day, five days a week is very difficult. We are both very active in our ordinary daily routines, and, without a concerted daily walk, we fall short by two or three thousand steps. Pity the poor devils trapped in car pools that extrude them directly into cubicles where they face computer screens all day.

We are very fortunate in being physically able to walk long distances and put in about three miles a day over and above just living. This gets us well over the health professionals recommended total. But office dwellers, those housed with small children, and most elderly folks are in a terrible fix when it comes to attaining the requisite strides each day.

But it’s not to worry; we all end up in the same eternal resting field, and postponing it is not necessarily the best way to get there. I’m reminded of the old Milton Berle quip, “They say jogging adds years to your life. I began today and feel ten years older already.” Uncle Miltie lasted until he was ninety-three without his 10K steps; to top that he was sharp till the end.

Blog on!

Wild Bill

Thursday, January 12, 2006

Amend the Constitution

Accountants, actuaries, economists, mathematicians, engineers, statisticians, physicists, finance specialists, budget examiners, cashiers, but especially MBAs should be disqualified from running for President of the United States. This blog posting is my opening salvo in calling for a Constitutional Amendment prohibiting anyone able to pass an eighth grade test on four function arithmetic from becoming our chief executive.

Let’s get right to it; Jimmy Carter and Herbert Hoover demonstrated beyond any doubt that they knew the price of everything and the value of nothing. They could add, subtract, multiply and divide better than any other incumbents of the Oval Office. But Hoover has yet to deliver that chicken for every pot, and poor Jimmy is still wondering why the American people are suffering from a malaise over the price gas when it went over a buck.

But George W. Bush takes the cake. His MBA from Harvard renders him able to see that the Iraq War will cost no more than $70 billion, that a defined contributions Social Security program will make all Americans rich, that Brownie’s doing a heck of a job, that tax reductions for the rich are the best thing that ever happened to the poor in New Orleans, that oil revenue will pay for the war and reconstruction in Iraq, that he is the best interpreter of the Constitution, that budget and trade deficits stretching from here to your great grandchildren are good for us, and he has a gazillion more answers to policy questions yet to be asked.

Much as we denigrate lawyers, actors and philosophers, at least we have to acknowledge they never try make things add up. George Washington kept his mouth shut by munching on wooden teeth. Thomas Jefferson concluded that it was unconstitutional to make the Louisiana Purchase until Napoleon was in need of a quick financial fix. Abe Lincoln went to about the fourth grade. FDR was labeled a second rate intellect, and Ronald Reagan – well you know that he couldn’t add up anything. But all these guys did great.

So it’s clear, if you can do anything higher than algebra I, you shouldn’t be allowed anywhere near the nuclear button. Got it?

You heard it here first.

Blog on!

Wild Bill

Wednesday, January 11, 2006

That's a "T" - two of 'em

That’s two with a “T” trillion dollars. A Columbia University Nobel Prize Laureate in economics and a Harvard professor have done an analysis of the long term costs of the Iraq War and come up with a figure of close to two trillion dollars for this misbegotten experiment of imposing democracy on a tribal nation far, far away. Even conservative thinkers are piling on Bush for this one. Just think, this tab will have to be paid by our children and grandchildren. Now there's the great legacy of the Bush administration.

Before even one soldier or marine stepped onto the beach, Larry Lindsey was banished to the world beyond the White House for even hinting the effort might cost up to two hundred billion dollars, that’s billion with a “B”. The maximum amount that administration officials could talk about prior to the invasion without having to face the world from a cubicle in the private sector was seventy billion dollars. Each month, the military chews up 4.5 billion in direct costs alone and that adds up to a quarter of a trillion spent and we're nowhere near getting out.

Going on three years into the conflict, we’re still unable to assure soldiers and marines patrolling bomb laden streets that they are wearing the latest in body armor which costs the princely sum of $285 per combatant. As a result of this and a lot more, the indirect costs of the war in terms of disability and death benefits for those killed and wounded continues to skyrocket without even considering the human cost.

All of the pre invasion baloney about Iraq’s oil covering the cost of the conflict smells as bad as if we’d hung that processed meat out to rot in the hot desert sun. Iraqi oil production stands at about half of pre war levels, and, even if it didn’t, it couldn’t come close to covering the cost of even the direct costs of the war.

But the Iraqis should be grateful. We’ve delivered them a democratic government. In 230 years, they’ll be thanking Allah that America came and made them a free and united country.

We’re staying till we win! Damn it, we won! Let’s get the hell out of Dodge!

Blog on,

Wild Bill

Monday, January 09, 2006

The Madness of Wild Bill

Every journey begins with a single step, but this morning it began with the touch of a button. All I’ve been reading about for months is the need for us to take ten thousand steps each day in order to keep the old bod functioning properly. As I’ve been tearing calendar pages for longer than I care to remember and, feeling quite chipper, thank you very much, since I find that task quite pleasant, I decided to live forever and take my first ten thousand steps per day starting on rising this morning.

To digress, I have been into cardio vascular exercise for many years, so this is not quite as outrageous as it sounds. I took up jogging and later running when in my late forties and backed down to purposeful walking when I passed sixty. The task was twofold: to be able to walk the full eighteen holes of my once a week spoiled walk at the local golf course and to maintain what remained of my CV fitness level. They say that walking a round of golf amounts to about six miles. In my case, that’s quite conservative as `spraying the ball about’ is a kind way to describe my game. So I had little doubt that on Mondays making 10K steps was assured.

Most other days of the week I walk with purpose through my neighborhood for some two and a half to three and a half miles and was content with the effort. But no, the health mavens never let it go at that; it’s no longer thirty (or, later, forty) minutes of strong steady walking to assure the bankruptcy of the Social Security Trust Fund, it’s ten thousand steps.

What’s a senile old man to do? Why head for Radio Shack and buy an electronic pedometer, that’s what. Of course, I spent three hours completely glued to my seat reading the instructions and must have missed three or four thousand opportunities to degrade my hips and knees and add to my CV fitness. Notwithstanding the difficulties associated with comprehending instructions originally written in Chinese and translated into English in a galaxy far, far away, I was ready to embark on my journey at the point of dawn.

On arising, I quickly concluded that I had already shorted myself by maybe fifty steps taken between bed, bath and beyond before successfully attaching the horrible little appendage to my belt. Ten thousand steps would be easily achieved but I’d have to be alert to the need to add steps for such obvious errors against my total.

But on the way to my first cup of coffee, I made a horrible discovery. On moving between cupboard, refrigerator, stove, and breakfast table, I was getting credit for all kinds of mini steps. Reach for napkin – one step; back to the right for sugar, another. Surely the mavens don’t mean the 10 thousand pity pats which are adding up so quickly before I even injected my first cc of caffeine or read the headlines?

Naturally, I’m in crisis, and a deep angst has settled about the house. Really, I should have gotten credit for about fifty steps before the official count began. But what about the couple of hundred I was granted for hardly stepping at all while reaching for the margarine and sugar?

I won’t tell what I paid for the device that is already giving me chest pains – or for the one I bought the wife since she too seems intent on super longevity. By the way, within minutes of arriving in the kitchen, she was howling about the inaccuracy of her new medical marvel. This, of course, has doubled my need for nitroglycerin under the tongue.

I’ve decided to add a hundred steps for various omissions and to subtract a thousand for pity pat steps and for unmentionable bathroom activities. But at the end of the day, I fully expect to be able a certify to those in the public health sector carefully watching over me that I made my ten thousand steps and that I need my angina medicine prescription renewed.

Are you sure that you’re taking ten thousand steps each day? I see no alternative to purchasing a pedometer to be sure. Oh, and pick one up for the spouse while you’re at it.

Blog on!

Wild Bill

Saturday, January 07, 2006

Wake Up, Plutocrats

IBM is the latest major American company to cease its defined benefits pension program i.e., a pension that pays so much per year based on so much income and a certain amount of service. Based on clear evidence that has come forward over the past several decades, corporations no matter how rich understand that greater life spans of recipients, economic uncertainty, a changed tax and accounting situation, and competition from abroad mandate pension reform. And that means reform now and even more so in the years ahead. The end of defined benefits pensions in favor of defined contributions programs – those in which the employee and the employer put aside tax deferred income for the employees benefit during retirement - is upon us. This is a good thing for the national economy and for the American worker, as without such reforms, more jobs than ever will be shipped abroad. The trend is clear; the end of American pension programs as we know them is at hand.

Even government programs must be adjusted. The federal government bit the bullet and beginning in 1981, all new employees began work with a significantly scaled back defined benefits program and began a defined contributions program very much akin to those being offered in the private sector. I never cared much for Jimmy Carter, but that’s one he can take credit for.

State and local pension programs are creating fantastic problems for the governments and their citizens, and only lately have politicians begun to look realistically at them. Reforms much like that of the federal government or the private sector are inevitable if states, cities, and towns are to avoid bankruptcy. This is, however, the third rail of our federal system, but it must be faced by the politicians and the citizens despite the outcry from powerful public employee unions or disaster will overwhelm us all.

With that setup, what’s my point? Simple, Social Security must be saved as a defined benefit program and funding reform must occur soon. President Bush did us both a great favor and a disservice with his effort to reform the system last year. By highlighting the need for reform, the voters were made aware of the problem, but by demanding that reform be in the form of a defined contribution system he frightened both old and young and by being unwilling to consider how the defined benefit program might be funded, he assured that the problem would be more difficult to solve when Americans realize what we’re facing in terms of far more recipients and fewer contributing workers.

But The United States is much better off than many of its modern industrial competitors. Our population is younger than those of the European countries and Japan and is growing older far more slowly. Say what you will, but immigration gives us time to deal with the problems of our aging workforce and we must seize the opportunity.

I hope I’m wrong, but next to nothing is likely to be done to deal with the problems of Social Security and Medicare during the next three years. This will be one of the lasting legacies of this terrible presidency. Mr. Bush’s hubris in what he was demanding for Social Security reform is almost equal to that of his misbegotten Iraq War and we will all pay for it.

Despite living in the largest and most dynamic economy in the history of man, we cannot afford everything. That conservatism has highlighted this `there is no free lunch’ situation for more than a generation, many of those able to defend themselves have done so, but huge numbers – and a high percentage - of our population have been unable to assure any kind of economic security for themselves as they approach old age, and they live in utter fear that the one great benefit coming out of the New Deal, Social Security, will not be there for them when they can no longer work.

The Republican plutocracy simply cannot fathom this fear and their proposal for Social Security reform demonstrates how out of touch with the masses they really are. The GOP is fortunate, however, that millions of good people with deep religious convictions and of high moral values have been gulled into supporting many of their worst programs because they cannot abide what the Evangelical leaders have labeled as evil. The eyes of these people are opening, however, and the Democrats, too, are beginning to heed their message and to court these nice folks.

Millions of our citizens cannot face a future in which they are dependent on a Dickensonian system of private handouts and a dole. That paying into a Social Security system for a lifetime could result in poor choices leading to a dotage of impoverishment is simply too much for them to contemplate. With each passing day another corporation throws in the sponge on its pension program and even upper middle income workers fear that there will be no floor under their benefits.

Democrats, independents and moderate Republicans must understand that Social Security must be saved in its present form and the rising costs must be addressed soon. Accountants, actuaries, economists, and plutocrats can proclaim the benefits of compounding till the cows come home and can demonstrate in black and white that the country would be better off under the system proposed by President Bush; it doesn’t matter, a society is held together by a social compact that is greater than sheer logic. There is a great fear of failure out there and the one shining light in the window for all to home in on is Social Security. “Let them eat cake,” is the obvious answer for those who fail. It isn’t a satisfactory response, and the Republicans better get with the program.

Blog on!

Wild Bill

Friday, January 06, 2006

Happy Days Are Here Again

A proposed and credible solution to the New Orleans problem that is worthy of Franklin Roosevelt has been offered. Congressman Richard Baker, a Republican from Baton Rouge, has proposed a scheme for overcoming the damage inflicted upon his state that is equal to any that could be conjured up by Harry Hopkins or Harold Ickes in their heyday, and I like it.

The New York Times reports that the solution involves spending up to eighty billion dollars of your hard earned tax money to pay off mortgages on destroyed property, to restore all of the infrastructure damaged and otherwise put out of commission by Hurricane Katrina, to buy up the land littered with refuse, to clean it all up, and to sell it all to developers for renewing the city. How cool is that?

Mr. Baker is one of the foremost critics of big government in the Congress, but it’s sure nice to know that when the chips are really down he knows where to turn and what to do. Step one: stop calling the Democrats big government spenders. Step two: forget everything bad you ever said about big government. Step three: write a multi-billion dollar proposal. And step four: just to show you haven’t gone soft, call for a tax cut for the rich. (Wait, maybe the last item hasn’t been formulated yet.)

When things are really bad, it’s government that must fill the void. No other entity can step into the midst of a calamity of this magnitude and simply make the crucial things happen. We need New Orleans and the nearby ports and infrastructure, and if the feds don’t make it happen, it won’t, at least to the level required for commerce on the Mississippi and to support the people in the countryside. I really am for it all.

But I hark back not to my first public hero, FDR, but to a Republican, William Cohen of Maine, who really saw the situation with a clear eye. “Government is the enemy until you need a friend.” Mr. Baker, after a lifetime of criticism, has seen the light; he needs a friend, one with deep pockets and lots of muscle. Hallelujah! Better late than never.

Now Mr. Baker has a serious problem; he has to convince all those free market buddies of his on the right side of the aisle in both houses to support this bailout. Lord Almighty, what a chore. Well maybe it’s not quite that bad; maybe three fourths of the Democrats will support his bill and he’ll only have to convince half the majority to join him and his new allies.

It’s an ill wind that blows no good. Congressman Baker is now a supporter of big `govment’ as his hero the Gipper called it, and I suppose that he’ll be switching parties over the next few months. My goodness, these pols will do almost anything to get re-elected? I guess all his big money backers – at least those who’ll profit from the venture - will have to get that old time `Solid South’ religion too.

Don’t say the leopard can’t change his spots. For a humongous federal windfall, down there in the land of Huey they’ll paint that sucker chartreuse and make him say he likes it.

And it’s catching, Ahnold’s unveiled an almost equally ambitious New Deal program of renewal in California. The ghost of FDR is smiling.

Blog on!

Wild Bill

Thursday, January 05, 2006

El Rushbo

While running errands for the queen yesterday, I turned to my copilot in such situations, El Rushbo. He was rampaging over the mainstream media’s (MSM) efforts to undermine Bush as a result of the mine disaster in West Virginia. He was lobbing grenades in all directions and asserting that the MSM has lost all credibility and that all they think about any issue was how it might be brought to bear in ruining the president.

In trying to fashion some sort of reaction to Limbaugh’s diatribe, my only conclusion was that he was simply full of baloney.

The Federal Government has a responsibility for assuring good practices and for enforcing rules and regulations assuring compliance with safety standards. The old Bureau of Mines was responsible for this activity until it was abolished in 1996 and the safety functions were transferred from the Bureau in the U.S. Department of the Interior to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, NIOSH.

The institute’s web site is full of self promotion on how great it is in promoting mine safety. “We have a long and rich history of advancing mine worker safety and health.” On and on it goes in this vein. Hey, bozos, take it down at least till this blows over!

Published reports indicate that the mine involved in the tragedy has a long history of safety violations and of rejecting the findings of the feds. And of course mine safety laws and regs have been watered down to the absolute minimum. After all, what’s K Street for?

But all of the facts and findings will come out in the media and in civil and criminal court proceedings. The purpose of this posting is just to Take Rush to task for his vein popping outburst against the media and nothing more.

This terrible event is not one that I’d drop at the president’s doorstep were I a member of the MSM media, but, to pursue Rush’s point, why isn’t this Bush’s responsibility? He’s the president and by extension is charged with enforcing federal laws. Mine safety comes directly under the Secretary of Health and Human Services a Bush political appointee. The NIOSH chief, in turn, is an employee of the Executive Branch and, therefore, any dereliction or misfeasance by NIOSH runs directly to where the buck stops.

I’m not after Mr. Bush on this issue. Rather I’m just pointing out that Rush was simply blowing smoke. He does it all the time on a hundred issues. I listen to him for entertainment while I’m running errands for the wife. I make a point of listening to who is sponsoring the program to be sure to withhold my custom from them – unless, of course, it’s a pharmaceutical company keeping me going. But the ranter has a daily audience in the millions who froth along with him. My question is why does he have a following? He warps everything. He attacks the mainstream media who are leagues ahead of him in truth and honor. Nobody’s perfect, but Rush is not only not close to being accurate, he doesn’t even try.

Of course Rush is not the worst; he’s mean spirited but at least he’s funny. The rest of the right wing bomb throwers are far worse; they have no humor. My excuse for listening is that it’s ten minutes every other day while driving and I want to hear what the yahoos are being fed. If you’re getting more than that, isn’t it time for a review? Are you really that angry?

Blog on!

Wild Bill

Wednesday, January 04, 2006

Happy New Year

Okay, alright already, I didn’t last a week into the new year. So who said I was strong? Besides, this isn’t really about Iraq – not all about it anyway.

Many have opined that there are three major schools for jihadists in operation today, the Caucuses, Afghanistan, and Iraq, with the last being the largest, most advanced, and of our own making. It is clear that President Bush is preparing to withdraw most of our forces from Iraq and to permit the government in Baghdad sink or swim, and we’re getting set to turn over only partially completed infrastructure to the Iraqis all the while declaring that the police and army look better to us each day.

This must be killing the neocons and Bush’s other core supporters of the war. All they talk about is how well things are really going over there and how the media isn’t telling the real story. When we walk away, they’re really fearful that they were the ones dreaming.

Even more cynical than I, some, including Eugene Robinson of the Washington Post, speculate that our troops will pour out of Iraq until after the ’06 Congressional elections and then – after a close but positive outcome for the Republicans - be reinserted based on new dangers on the ground. “Who could have known?” being the innocent reaction from the White House.

The Republicans are having a hard time. Their scandal – yes it’s theirs; it’s their government lock, stock, and barrel or should I say executive, legislative, and court – exposes once again that power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely. Their shenanigans on K Street show that politicians must be checked at every turn. I’m truly an admirer of pols, but you have to remember two things about them: they are the cleverest among us and they’re still just human beings. If you understand those two points, you can see why they must be held in check by every means possible, with divided government being the most effective tool in the citizens’ kit.

The GOP is petrified. Their values coalition crumbled in the face of the Terri Schiavo horror show. Deficits are killing those few in the party who label themselves true conservatives. Libertarians are going bonkers over civil liberties. Iraq has isolated the neocons within the coalition. And the defense contractors see their hard bought dollars flying into the desert having bought old fashioned bullets instead of high priced weapons systems. Brownie and the FEMA crowd have jeopardized the outcome in all those scarlet Gulf States. And now the K Street crowd has got the values tongues wagging all over again. There are flu symptoms everywhere Republicans gather.

So, in addition to perp walks for those caught and Medals of Freedom ceremonies for all who avoid indictment, the boys – and girls - have to come marching home so that the Republicans can get through 2006. That’s too cynical? Don’t bet on it.

Blog on!

Wild Bill

Tuesday, January 03, 2006

Johnny Still Can't Read

In keeping with my 2006 resolution to stay as far away from the Iraq War as possible, I’m going to try to focus on other things as long as I can - maybe a week.

College graduates can’t read. Whew, who’d ‘a thunk it?

Our economy demands more and more skilled people and we’re turning out a greater number and higher percentage of college graduates than any generation preceding this one. Meanwhile, our newly discovered high power competitors, China and India, are cranking out high quality engineers, scientists, and English majors by the carload, what’s happening?

I surely don’t know, but one politically incorrect notion keeps creeping into my Busch addled brain; maybe the people we’re attempting to push through the higher education system aren’t up to it. We’re extruding a higher percentage of our kids through high school and on to the next level at an ever higher level. Hey, when the gene pool isn’t improving and the labor market calls for an ever increasing numbers of educated – or at least trained – entrants – or at least time servers - what happens? Could it be that the input quality goes down so far they can’t be trained to do those jobs?

With three or four times our population each, China and India have more – many more - smart people – in gross numbers - than we do. If they educate only those folks on the second, third, or even greater standard deviation above the norm in intelligence, they’re still educating a whole heck of a lot more folks than we are when we start dropping down to the first standard deviation below the bell. Look at it this way, when they educate twenty or thirty million of their best and brightest each year and we keep up in sheer numbers, we just can’t keep up when it comes to the overall quality of the output.

Remember when Johnny couldn’t read? Well we got the kinks out of that problem and most of those capable of reading could. Now Johnny’s grown kids can’t hack it. Give them a break, they used to get jobs down at the local plant; now they’re in the front office and they can’t read.

I don’t know the answer, but it’s not just pumping more money into the system or even injecting accountability into our schools. Maybe we’re getting down to the bottom of the barrel. Maybe we’ll just have to educate the educable and deal with the results. Kurt Vonnegut novels toyed with these problems half a century ago. The answers then weren’t very pretty either.

Wow, I’ll be getting a lot of email on this one. “Stick to Iraq, you don’t anything about that either but at least you’re only insulting George Bush.”

Blog on!

Wild Bill

Sunday, January 01, 2006

The Producers

Do you love great drama? Timeless soliloquies? Great love affairs? Forget The Producers.

Do you adore silly schmaltz? Over the top acting? Hokum and Bunkum? Laughing till you cry? Have I got a flick for you! Mel Brooks has been absent from the silver screen for far too long, but he bursts forth brilliantly with his rewritten musical comedy.

The wife and I ventured forth on a foul Saturday afternoon and joined a movie house full of aging laugher wannabes in a suburban mall for a couple of hours of escapism. We got it in full measure.

The story line is worn and has been recycled many times, but the sheer audacity of the dialogue and the brilliance of the cast made this an afternoon to remember. Nathan Lane and Mathew Broderick are well known commodities, and their counterpoint playing was wonderful but fully expected. But Will Farrell as the demented playwright injects a madness reminiscent of the old time Brooks movies that was – I think – missing from the first movie made from this material.

Lane really is equal to Zero and Broderick misses not a step in keeping up with Mel, but Farrell steals their wallets every time he appears.

The minor players are also wonderful. None of the songs seems destined for immortality, but some of the production numbers are as well done as in any musical play turned to film. Farrell’s auditioning number is a howler, and the dance of the aging widow play backers draws tears from the assembled.

When it ended, the audience broke out into spontaneous applause. This is a harmless, silly movie and audiences simply don’t do this.

Spend the money!

Blog on!

Wild Bill

Saturday, December 31, 2005

Happy New Year

It’s been a very strange year. George Bush entered his second term completely full of himself. He told the country the way it was going to be; he had plenty of political capital and he intended to spend it. Social security was going to be reformed – and I mean reformed – and anyone who didn’t like it could lump it. Democracy was going to be delivered to the people of Iraq and that success would be a model for the broader Middle East. The cat was on top of his game, and the Republicans were in charge from now till as far as you could see out on the flat West Texas prairie.

Well the year didn’t turn out as scripted. The president’s efforts to turn Social Security into a defined contribution program fell like a cow flap on that same flat land. The AARP which had been playing footsie with Bush turned on him like a scorned woman. The elderly were skittish and even the young put up `no sale’ signs. When the reaction at every road show stop was that of a herd of deer in the headlights, it became clear that the effort was going nowhere. What’s really sad is that Bush was actually in a position to strengthen the defined benefit program, but he wouldn’t hear of that.

The president got caught by Mother Nature. While the professionals were well aware of the damage potential of a major hurricane on the Gulf Coast near New Orleans, politicians had successfully put off doing what was really needed to protect the lower Mississippi for generations, Bush was the guy stuck without a seat when the music stopped. But he compounded his problems by stocking top FEMA posts with Republican `must hire’ cronies. And his personal performance and statements like, “You’re doing a heck of job,” added to his woes.

But it always gets back to his real problem. George Bush can shift and slide. He can allude to a Congressional Resolution. He can talk about other countries thinking the same thing. He can point fingers at the U.N. He can run, but he can’t hide. Iraq is his war, his and his alone. It is the responsibility that cannot be palmed off on anyone. Iraq is George Bush’s personal tar baby.

But I’ve said all that I could possibly say about it. People near and dear to me say I’m obsessed with it and that history will decide if Bush is a visionary or a failed president. My vote is that he is a totally failed utopian who bet his presidency on a long term favorable outcome in Iraq, and it is only a matter of time before the croupier hauls in the chips. But time alone will tell.

I’m going to resolve to write about this calamity as seldom as possible in 2006. There can be no doubt among my readers about my opinion. Most days I’m angry and want vindication, and I feel guilt over that. Today, I’m stepping back and hoping with all my heart that I’m wrong.

In any event, I resolve to wake up tomorrow looking for a happy and prosperous New Year for all of us, and I hope that George Bush is able to extricate our troops quickly, that Iraq’s government holds, and that our investment of blood and treasure was not in vain.

Blog on!

Wild Bill

Thursday, December 29, 2005

Kennedy Center Honors

The Kennedy Center Honors were on television this week. As many of you undoubtedly know, the Honors have become the highest and greatest reward that performing artists can attain for lifetime achievement. The event itself happens several weeks earlier than the televising and it is about the toughest ticket in Washington. (One has to be careful of hyperbole since the Redskins are returning to glory under Coach Joe Gibbs.) Since tickets ran as high as $6,250 per seat, it mattered not that I wasn’t among the anointed in attendance at the Center.

But the program was not as critically well received as in past years, and Barbara and I sat through the show with less than complete enthusiasm ourselves.

After it was over, I began to dissect the situation to try to find the reason. My conclusion is that the Honors much like many forms of media are not satisfying for a host of reasons. As newspaper readership is dropping and television ratings of news shows are down in favor of the newer vehicle, the internet, so the Honors are suffering a malaise.

One of the problems with newspapers – and cable TV and many other media - is the need to bundle. People have far less time to read morning papers and those who read them dive for their favorite sections, be it news, business, sports, style (culture), whatever. Thus half or more of the paper lies unread. Even we retired folks who devour our papers over multiple cups of coffee ignore many sections. I myself have not read half a dozen stories in the food sections of papers I’ve subscribed to over the course of my life and there are other sections that I only skim.

Newspaper companies assert that they are unable to unbundle the sections and deliver them profitably. Advertisers demand as much coverage as possible, and specialty papers covering only sports, news, etc. just wouldn’t attract the number of subscribers needed to support the venture.

Awards programs have been about specialties, albeit broad ones. The Oscars are for movies, Tony awards are for excellence on Broadway, Country Music Awards are self explanatory, and the list goes on. The Kennedy Center was looking for a niche and it found it in lifetime achievement in the performing arts, and for many years the novelty worked very well. Unfortunately, the niche was built on major league bundling, and that meant that the live audience in the Center and the TV viewers were people with the normal range of likes and dislikes.

In the early years, the unique nature of the awards made putting up with the minor inconvenience of sitting through presentations to artists whom we’d never heard of and arts we didn’t care for just a small price to pay for the larger show. But much as I hate to admit it, I’ve become an elitist who cares greatly for stage and movie actors and many types of classical music performers, but I pick and choose among the more popular forms of entertainment – arts. While I like Willy Nelson, I’m not much of a Tina Turner admirer, even though I find her act occasionally entertaining.

My problem is sitting through a two hour show while being passionately interested in only one, two or, occasionally, three of the honorees. It’s the bundling. Thus, I enjoy the acting, directing and writing portions of the Academy Awards but skip the Country Music Awards. The Kennedy Center however creative and deserving the honorees leaves me with from forty to sixty percent of the program that I could easily skip.

No matter how well they do it and no matter how great the artists, a lot of the audience doesn’t really care about some of the arts and the price in time is becoming noticeable to critics and even the audience.

That’s truly unfortunate as the idea is wonderful.

Blog on!

Wild Bill

Wednesday, December 28, 2005

Bay State Blues

I’m a native of Massachusetts, from that great old industrial city, Brockton. I moved to Washington, DC area as a young man but returned to The Bay State in retirement to that lovely town on Buzzard’s Bay, Marion, and lived there for nine wonderful years.

Almost four years ago, my wife and I returned to the National Capital Area to be near our children and grandchildren, but I maintain a keen interest in what goes in The Old Colony, indeed all of New England And many of my readers hail from that neck of the woods.

Not unique but relatively rare, I have a lot of experience with local and state government in New England and in places that organize quite differently – county v. town. I’ll post something in the near future on my take on the differences, but, today, I want to focus on a contemporary issue in Massachusetts, health care financing.

I know too many economists – family, friends, acquaintances, neighbors - and wind up chatting with more of them at cocktail parties than all other species combined. Being a shrinking violet, as my readers know well, I am at a great disadvantage in this intercourse. While these economists are often brilliant, they tend, unlike wild Bill, to be very opinionated about everything, but I find that they really do know their stuff when it comes to their specialty.

Today, I’m featuring Walt Francis who last week wrote the very helpful posting on choosing a Medicare prescription drug plan that was put up on this site. That piece drew more favorable comment than any other single posting ever.

Massachusetts is one of only three states that are losing population. The angst this has created has caused more navel gazing than anything in recent memory. About two decades ago, the Commonwealth found itself losing ground against its competitors and a popular revolt against the perceived enemy came about. Taxachusetts was the laughing stock of the nation and jobs were heading south, literally. Proposition 2 ½ put a lid on local taxes and the state recovered nicely, and, while the high tax label was never shed, the state moved down the list of heavy taxers quite a way.

Today the culprits are the high cost of living - especially housing and health care, the loss of manufacturing, and social issue – including immigration. Again the angst over loss of economic and political position is driving the residents batty.

Yesterday’s Boston Globe had a very well written argument on why state law should be changed to mandate that employers be required to cover the health care of workers. Again, while wonderfully argued, I found it to be completely without merit as a way to solve the economic and political problems that raised the issue.

Here’s a link to the op-ed piece in question:
http://www.boston.com/news/globe/editorial_opinion/oped/articles/2005/12/27/the_health_insurance_meltdown?p1=email_to_a_friend

I asked Walt to look at the article and to give me his views. His opinion tracks mine exactly, except that he knows what he’s talking about. So I’m posting this and mailing it to my readers with known New England connections.

Here Walt’s take:

”The details of the Massachusetts scheme are not given. A similar scheme recently enacted in Maryland would only tax employers who do not spend 8 percent of their payroll on health care, and apply only to very large employers. In fact, it is believed to apply only to one employer in the state: Walmart. Regardless, all such schemes have the same bogus justification, seek to dictate the details of employer benefit design, and generally fall under the rubric of "feel good insanity." The spurious rationale is that if workers are uninsured the taxpayer will bear the brunt. I suppose so, to the extent that the State so elects. But no deity mandated that Massachusetts or Maryland taxpayers pay for any worker's health care. By the same rationale, if workers don't have good pensions, the taxpayers will bear the brunt in Supplemental Security Income payments to the elderly poor. If workers don't have employer-funded contraceptives who knows what the taxpayers may have to pay in welfare benefits? Why not mandatory life insurance subsidies to make sure there are no impoverished widows and orphans? If workers don't have cars to drive to work, they might become a burden on the unemployment insurance system, and who better than employers to pay automobile purchase and repair subsidies? Where shall the cornucopeia end?Where it will end is in the relocation of entrepreneurs to states not seized of mandatory benefit frenzy. WalMart is perfectly capable of locating super stores on the Delaware, Pennsylvania, and Virginia borders of Maryland, to say nothing to some creative accounting for its Maryland books. Nobody forces Internet firms who hire only the youngest and brightest (and cheapest to insure) to maintain work forces in Massachusetts. Nobody forces Massachusetts firms to hire full time workers who show up on payrolls rather than to hire through contracts to temporary worker firms or subsidiaries located in other states. And nobody forces Massachusetts firms to stay in state rather than relocate to New Hampshire (where many of their workers live anyway).Where shall the equity lines be drawn? Maryland at least would exempt 99.9 percent of firms in the State. Does Massachusetts intend to require the local hot dog stand to purchase group health insurance for its owner operator? Nationally, relatively few small businesses provide employer-financed health insurance--does Massachusetts seek to impose costly new requirements on them, imposed by no other state in the union? Or is the Massachusetts proposed law aimed only at WalMart, and purely symbolic "feel goodism." Has either state bothered to consult an economist? Folks in that profession will advise them that over time the entire effect of the mandated benefit will fall on workers, who will lose essentially dollar for dollar in dollar wages the amount spent on insurance benefits. Of course, one might argue the broader social benefits are well worth overriding worker preferences. Perhaps, but some workers have insurance elsewhere (through spouses, for example), and other workers are more interested in sending dollar wages to relatives abroad who would otherwise starve. Has any legislator in either state considered that workers in the state already have the luxury of deciding whether to work for an employer who offers "good" health insurance and one who does not, and have decided, by voting with their employment applications, on the mix of salary and fringe benefits that they prefer? No one has to take a job as a WalMart greeter. It is really quite remarkable how wise are the solons in these states who know better the needs and wants of every single worker in the state than the workers themselves.Proposals like these illustrate the high cost we pay for the economic illiteracy of most legislators, to say nothing of the arrogance of those who, like the latter day czars of the Soviet Union and the Platonists among us, believe that omniscient, all-powerful government can better arrange the affairs of men than private decisions freely arrived at. One can only hope that these states will pay an economic price so high as to dissuade any others from similar folly.”

As you can see, Walt, unlike your regular contributor, is a bit of a polemicist. But he’s right and Massachusetts lawmakers really ought to look at things other than this solution to their problems.

Blog on!

Wild Bill

Tuesday, December 27, 2005

Read and Weep

In reading today’s Boston Globe online, I found an extraordinary comparison of the similarities and differences between our national calamities in Vietnam and Iraq. H.D.S. Greenway worked as a correspondent in Vietnam and now writes for the Globe, so he has more than a passing knowledge of these tragic conflicts.

The most frightening thing to me is the similarity in the mindsets of both eras – how delusional our political and military leaders become in such situations.

It is particularly saddening to realize that brilliant people like Donald Rumsfeld who were present and in a position to understand the lessons of Vietnam could be fooled by their own hubris into believing that they through sheer will power and overarching American military technology could trump human nature. How sad.

The appointed leaders must be dismissed and the elected officials leading the charge must be turned out.

Read and weep.


http://www.boston.com/news/globe/editorial_opinion/oped/articles/2005/12/27/how_will_the_iraq_war_end?p1=email_to_a_friend

Blog on!

Wild Bill

Monday, December 26, 2005

Grandma Said

When I was very little boy, my maternal grandmother warned me that, “Murder will out.” I didn’t understand her at the time.

When I was in the second grade, our teacher left the room, and I led a relatively harmless insurrection. We drew graffiti on the blackboards and stomped all about. It was really fun; about thirty little boys and girls having a ball. I felt great; my leadership had made it all happen.

After about five minutes, we heard Miss Dighton returning and flew to our seats; so much for that escapade.

Not so fast! While I know that thoughts of bamboo shoots being shoved under the finger nails of my classmates were what caused the calamity, it took only one question from authority to discover the culprit. “Who started this?”

That twenty-nine fingers could point so rapidly and accurately was beyond my comprehension and a beautiful circle of guilt centered on the felon. It took less than ten seconds for me to be identified, arrested, and convicted.

I drew one lesson from that fiasco that has never left me: never conspire to do anything even vaguely criminal. If I ever thought about committing felonies after that day – and I have never been convicted of any such activities – I assure you those thoughts never included partners in crime.

That’s what I learned in the second grade and when I finally understood Grandma’s warning.

When The Pentagon Papers were released and the darkest secrets of Vietnam were made public, I made a quick connection of the dots back to my second grade experience. Obviously, after the insider revelations about Tyco and Enron, it was clear that such dots were not limited to the public sector. Conspiring to suppress what bad or questionable things you might be doing isn’t smart.

Unfortunately for our president and quite a few others on his team, they led far too sheltered lives and never listened to their Grandmas or paid attention to what happened in virtually every elementary school in the history of our species. Murder will out and don’t conspire. Is there more basic advice than that?

When they played games with the NSA, it was only a matter of time before someone outed them.

I think what they did was stupid and that those big boys and girls are going to find that out. I was seven years old. They’re all over fifty. Slow Learners, I’d say.

Blog on!

Wild Bill

Saturday, December 24, 2005

Cream Puffs in the Cabinet

There was an interesting column in the Boston Globe this morning (12/24/05) by Robert Kuttner. Referring to Doris Kearns's new book about Abraham Lincoln, Team of Rivals, Kuttner opines that Bush could learn a lot in running his administration from the sixteenth president. I’ve attached the article and recommend it as solid reading.

http://www.boston.com/news/globe/editorial_opinion/oped/articles/2005/12/24/what_bush_couldlearn_from_lincoln?p1=email_to_a_friend

But I think that Kuttner missed the opportunity to discuss something far more fundamental as it relates to our current chief executive. Mr. Bush rarely misses the opportunity to say that we are a nation at war and that his most important role is to defend us in the conflict. That said, with the exception of Defense, his key cabinet spots are occupied by cronies and the powerless: State – Rice, Justice – Gonzales, Treasury – Snow.

A nation at war requires that we all pull together. Lincoln put together a cabinet representing a wide swath of public and political opinion in the Union States. But we shouldn’t forget that often when the nation was on war footing and perceived to be in danger the president reached across factional lines and appointed key officials with different political views from his own. Franklin Roosevelt matched Lincoln with a number of key Republicans in such spots as War, Navy, and Interior.

Even when the guns were quiet but the nation was perceived to be in great peril presidents such as Kennedy reached across the spectrum for key advisors such as Allen Dulles at CIA and Dillon at Treasury who provided broader and better advice than can ever be possible from the incestuous group of insider toadies assembled by Bush.

From the beginning, Mr. Bush wanted only the advice he wanted, and he got it. The Iraq War and his assault on the defined benefit program of Social Security among many others show just how insular his presidency is.

Mr. Kuttner’s point should be enlarged and examined. Because Mr. Bush wants only good news, that’s what he gets until the cigar with the firecracker blows up in his face. Everyone in the house was supportive of what was done in Iraq, but George Bush is catching the spears. Everyone on the team was supportive of his Social Security fiasco, but he’s the one labeled stupid.

The president better broaden the sources of input, even to the level of minor discomfort. Better a small turd on the cabinet conference table than a major fiasco being reported by all of the media outlets.

Three years is a long time to go. How long does it take to learn these lessons? Too long, I guess.

Merry Christmas, Happy Hanukkah, Happy Kwanzaa, and Happy Boxing Day; I’m shutting down for a couple of days to count my blessings and enjoy my family.

Blog on!

Wild Bill

Friday, December 23, 2005

Baloney by Bush

President Bush and Vice President Cheney are making aggressive defenses of the administration’s controversial wire tapping program that has bubbled up into the public eye in the past week. Their latest push is to have the judges on the court that is supposed to evaluate the need for warrants in such circumstances briefed so that they may learn why this program is constitutional.

After they’ve brow beaten these judges, they’re hoping the controversy will go away. But since one judge has already resigned in protest, they have to limit their lashing of the others at sub torture levels. This technique worked so well on CIA analysts in the run up to the Iraq War it’s no wonder they’re trying it again. No pressure, you understand, just stand over them and glare at them till they get it.

The president is also aggressively moving to defend the program by indicating that his most solemn duty is to protect the country. I came across a letter to the editor of the New York Times that deflates that notion far better than I ever could. Mr. Jeff Bialik of San Rafael, California gently points out that Mr. Bush’ most solemn responsibility is to uphold his oath to “preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution of The United States.”

I was then going to rip Mr. Bush for his false logic in defense of his position, but here too I found someone who had already done the job better than I ever could. Ellen Goodman in her column, Bush’s False Choices, in today’s Boston Globe strips back the false logic and shows the president for what he is: a president infected with grandiosity. I invite you to click on this clear eyed analysis.

http://www.boston.com/news/globe/editorial_opinion/oped/articles/2005/12/23/bushs_false_choices?p1=email_to_a_friend

Enough said for today!

Blog on!

Wild Bill

On Rereading

I golf using what one company selling a playing method it calls, `Natural Golf.’ I don’t play often – about once a week during the warmer months – or very well. But I have been using this method for several years. What I learned from reading their book - which is pretty good - is that by following their instructions, practicing a little and trying to employ their techniques as carefully as possible, I could improve. That isn’t earth shattering but it’s true.

What I’ve learned is that by rereading the instructions in a reasonably good how to book, you can better understand what the experts are driving at. Again, this is no big deal. More important, I’ve learned that by rereading other kinds of books one can gain new insights into what the author intended and, unless one is very well versed in the subject, rereading is an extraordinarily valuable technique.

I’m very interested in Existentialism – me and ten million others. Over the years, I’ve read quite a few books and articles on this subject and only became vaguely familiar with the intricacies of the subject. Using my little golf book as my guide, I began a systematic review and rereading of the thousands of pages of the books and articles on the subject that I own. The results are clear to me; by going over the material twice or even three or four times I have gained many insights into what some of the leading thinkers meant.

I’m no Camus, Sartre, Nietzche, or Kierkegaard and never will be; that was never my goal. But I do think that I understand – at least somewhat better than I did - and had even hoped until the last few years. I am neither a serious thinker nor scholar of Existentialism or anything else, but I think I’ve learned something useful. Repetition makes for a far greater understanding of whatever you’re interested in.

By repetition – or rereading – I don’t mean the kind that is required in school; that is of reading and going over material until you have it down for a test. What I’m driving at is going over material after extended periods of digesting it and after what was read is nearly cleared from memory. I’m rereading a book on Existentialism that I read and semi-enjoyed and understood about a year ago. In the interim, I’ve gone over a lot more material on the subject but still felt only marginally competent on the matter – again that's at my own very amateurish level.

But As I reread this book, many of the passages that were forgotten, obviously because they meant little to me earlier, came alive. I think that I understand what the author was driving at and it is making this rather difficult book a much more pleasant experience.

The purpose of this posting is not to interest you in Natural Golf or Existentialism – they’re not exactly out of the same course catalogue – but rather to encourage my older friends not to simply read and move on but to go over books about subjects they liked but which proved somewhat difficult the first time. There may be gems ready for mining the second time around. I’ve found this with how to, nonfiction and fiction.

Most of you may have known this all along. Indulge me, I’m a slow learner.

Blog on!

Wild Bill

Thursday, December 22, 2005

The Nation Mourns

By now everyone in Red Sox Nation has heard the word. Johnny Damon will not be patrolling center field for the old town team. Johnny served the nation with honor and played a huge part in winning the World Championship in 2004, and club management should be standing barefoot in the snow seeking the forgiveness of all of the citizens for permitting this travesty.

The nation can look back with pride and know that that the lads have accomplished goals barely dreamed of during the past century. We can be proud that the club is the only American League East team to win a world championship in this century, indeed in this millennium. Our hated rivals – and you know who they are – are basking in past and fast fading glory and in the joy of having stolen not only our great center fielder and lead off hitter but one of the leading intellectual lights of the Hub of the Universe. Best selling author Damon’s wondrous Transcendentalist book, Idiot: Beating “The Curse” and Enjoying the Game.

But all is not lost. Could Samson perform without his locks? It is reported that that Johnny will be introduced at a press conference later today, sans beard and hair. Can a proud `Dirt Bag’ find happiness in the perfectly pressed garb of a bourgeois uptight financial manager from Midtown? Never!

So it is unlikely that our poor lost son shorn of his hair will ever perform as well as he did in the Friendly Confines. To think that the poor boy will be required to shower before every road trip must be causing him great anxiety. How can he be expected to bat with that awful fact racking his lucre fevered brain?

I can’t imagine that the poor lost boy will ever find happiness in the Bronx. Showering, shaving, clean uniform, shiny helmet, and clean underwear every day; the thoughts of it must be giving him pause at this very moment. None the less, he signed the horrible paper.

And what else has he lost? Who’ll ever recognize him in New York? In Boston he was a real somebody. And his book, that’s the end of sales for that literary marvel; they say he was making ten thousand a year from that.

All that for George Steinbrenner’s cheap silver; I wish the hapless man well with the Evil Empire, and for just $52 million. Idiot!

Blog on!

Wild Bill

Wednesday, December 21, 2005

Rites of Spring - and a Mystery

Today, as the afternoon warmed, I felt a distinct change in the day. Low and behold, it’s the first day of spring. You remember how in a previous blog, It Might As Well Be Spring, posted on November 27, I abolished winter and summer, so it is indeed spring and even the red maples are showing signs of color in last year’s new branches and buds. I checked and the astronomers and climatologists confirmed the good news.

As promised in that earlier blog, at the appointed hour, I went into my garden and cavorted naked as called for in the primitive rites of spring. It was glorious feeling. The sun will return. There is hope for us.

A few minutes after returning to the house, I heard sirens. Apparently there were calls for ambulances to the neighborhood. It is sad that on such a joyous day not all are as healthy and happy as their aged neighbor, Wild Bill.

Shortly thereafter, another neighbor told me that the two young housewives, both barely of retirement age, who live in the properties flanking mine had collapsed nearly simultaneously for reasons unknown. They were taken to the hospital, treated and, thank goodness, released.

The mystery continued when the local Homeland Security people came by and asked nearby residents, including me, if we’d seen or heard anything unusual or blood curdling. Naturally, I was disappointed at not being to help but told them I was in my garden at about that time and observed and heard nothing out of the ordinary.

The young women were so traumatized by whatever they’d seen or heard that neither of them could recall anything about what had caused their anguish and physical collapse.

In any event, all’s well that ends well. It’s spring and they’ll be fine. Tomorrow, I’ll drop in on them with chicken soup. I’m certain that they’ll be pleased to see me; they always are.

Blog on!

Wild Bill

Tuesday, December 20, 2005

Odds and Ends - Big Ones

The president’s approval ratings are up…among his base supporters. It appears, however, that his major PR push over the last several weeks has paid off only with the faithful. Among Democrats and Independents there have been almost no positive changes in the ratings.

The revelation that the president authorized wiretapping of Americans without court orders is blowing up in his face. In today’s Washington Post, even conservative George Will was on his case and the only sign of support was a column written by neoconservatives.

The issue is ridiculous. According to The Boston Globe, the court in question has denied warrants in only four out of more than 5,200 requests over the past four years and, if it’s an emergency, the executive doesn’t even have to ask in advance. The agency simply does it and then asks for an ex post facto warrant; so much for the president’s ridiculous argument that the need for speed led to his order.

It’s very clear that members of this administration look not upon the Reagan Administration for its ideal as they so often indicate; they look to Richard Nixon’s relentless grasp for executive power as their example of how to restore the imperial presidency.

I’ve said it before there were things I liked about Nixon. He was the only president in my tenure that had some clue and inclination for managing the federal bureaucracy. Naturally, that positive led to a thousand negatives and ultimately to his less than happy departure into the setting sun.

As Nixon overreached then so is Bush now. The only thing I’ll say in his favor, he seems not to be exhibiting the obvious psychological strains that Nixon did when events started to spin out of his control in 1974.

Early results in the Iraqi election are going against the U.S. party line. Religious and ethnic parties seem to be the early winners. We were doing all we could for Interim Prime Minister Allawi and his buddies so now I guess Dubya is going to have to explain that electing mullahs was his plan all along.

Why on earth would anyone want to be president? I guess that’s why we get so few that exhibit signs of normalcy.

Blog on!

Wild Bill

Consignment – Bit Parts, B - Movies

Franklin Roosevelt once confided to Orson Welles that they were the two best actors in America. Many occupants of the White House recognized that the presidency was the greatest role on the largest stage in the world, and FDR was simply the first to spin it out in a stage whisper for all to hear. More than a generation later, the most accomplished practitioner of thespianism in the history of La Casa Blanca, Ronald Reagan, entered stage right, and his time in the role exceeded even Franklin’s at least for sheer show business acumen.

Apparently the present tenant of the Executive Mansion doesn’t realize some of his more illustrious predecessors were play acting and that when they said their lines many of them were for effect and not really carved in marble. FDR and the Gipper, for example, were among the most resolute of leaders and uttered among the strongest of proclamations. But lost on Bush 43 was the flexibility of Roosevelt and Reagan – and others; they were able to turn on a dime when it was warranted – or they were forced - and their ability to hide from their left hands what the rights were doing was sufficient to dazzle their audiences – if not their critics.

Watching Bush knuckle under to Senator John McCain on the torture issue and in other cases we see just what an amateur actor this president is; he fools no one when he claimed that it was his idea all along that torture should never be practiced in our names. This president is both rigid in his touch and incompetent in his ability to make the forced change in course to have been his, the captain’s, idea.

This president is also clumsy in presenting his arguments. For example, in Sunday (12/18/05) night’s speech he pounded his opponents for defeatism for thinking that the U.S. cannot win in Iraq. The number of his critics in Congress who are calling for immediate pullout is very small and his awkward attempts to lump those who are pushing for the fastest possible withdrawal from Iraq consistent with a reasonable chance for Iraqi success with extremists on the left just isn’t working. The majority of Bush’s critics – especially in Congress - of the war aren’t saying we can’t succeed at some level; they’re saying the price we’re paying for not getting out as quickly as possible is too high.

All of his efforts to cow his opponents for defeatism fail essentially because a greater number of people are coming to realize that he’s talking about the wrong subject. We attacked a country that was not a mortal threat to us or our friends, and we’re stuck with the president’s bad decision. Most of those opposed to the war are not calling for immediate pullout; we’re going along with him and those in Congress prodding him to get the troops out ASAP. His bad decision and his lack of presence are the reasons he can’t seem to pull this off.

And, of course, most of us opposed to what he’s wrought are fighting – apparently successfully – to keep the eyes of the voters on the calamity that the president created with his war. He didn’t keep his eye on the War on Terror, and down the pike many of those in Congress who continue to claque for him will be getting discharge papers from that conflict.

Maybe acting lessons would help. Na!

Blog on!

Wild Bill

Monday, December 19, 2005

Medicare Drug Benefits

Dear readers,

My friend Walt Francis is perhaps the foremeost authority on health insurance and health care financing in all of these United States. He has put together the following email and the attached analysis of the new and (at least to me) very confusing Medicare program on prescription drugs.

After reviewing it, I concluded that it was the first explanation of the program that I could understand. And you know that if I get it anyone can.

Walt sent this to his large mailing list of friends and encouraged us to pass it on to ours. I'm very pleased to send along this really valuable tool so that those of you on Medicare can make an informed decision and so you can forward it to others who are confused by the program.

I think this is a wonderful thing for Walt to have put together and thank him for all of you.

Wild Bill

Walt writes:

"Friends:I'm sending this out out most of my email list as a Christmas present to you and your family, friends, and neighbors. Deciding what to do about the new Medicare prescription drug benefit is really quite easy. It is not confusing and it is not complicated compared to things we do all the time, like buying a new car or deciding what book to read. No one should try to master the details of dozens of plans; just let the www.medicare.gov web site do the work for you.Please pass this on to persons on YOUR mailing list, to your neighbors, and to your family. (Yes, I know most of you are not 65 yet, but what about the folks next door?) The local help lines are badly backed up, but going online is simple, fast, and effective. And for those seniour without Internet savvy, what are friends, neighbors, and relatives for except to help?The attached file is a Microsoft Word file. It is two pages long. Just find the one or two paragraphs that apply to you, and get on with it! No more procastination!Walton Francis"


"The Simple Two-Page Guide to Medicare Part D Prescription Drug Insurance
Expert advice from Walton Francis, million selling book author of health insurance advice for Federal government employees and retirees--December 14, 2005 version.

The way for people on Medicare to deal with Part D is to sort themselves into the right category, and then start doing their homework.

If you have former employer coverage of drugs that is as good or better than Part D (like Federal retirees), or get your drugs from TRICARE or VA, you will waste money if you join Part D. If you have private employer coverage, you will probably lose it if you join Part D. With good coverage you can ignore Part D. However, if you are not sure whether that coverage is as good or better, read the "creditable coverage" letter from your former employer. If you are still not sure, call your former employer or the insurance plan. Be careful not to lose benefits!

If you are on Medicaid, the program that covers most low-income elderly, and most nursing home residents, you will be automatically enrolled. You can, however, still change from one plan to another. If you are in a “State Pharmaceutical Assistance Program” for limited-income persons you will probably be able to keep it and use it to supplement your Medicare benefit.

If you have a Medigap drug plan (H, I, J, or grandfathered), run, don't walk, to drop Medigap drug coverage and join a Medicare Advantage or Part D plan. Medicare drug coverage saves you about a thousand dollars a year compared to any Medigap drug plan. (The government pays three fourths of the Medicare premium, and you pay the whole Medigap premium, just for starters.) Some smart consumers will join new Medigap plans called K and L; these are better insurance deals than other Medigap plans for hospital and medical bills.

If you are already in a Medicare Advantage plan that combines filling in the holes in Medicare with drug coverage, it probably is getting better next year. But do check its details and consider shopping for an even better deal before you relax.

If you have a drug discount card, it is almost certainly either expiring, or dropping people with Medicare. Regardless, joining Medicare Part D is essential for anyone with expenses high enough to have needed a discount card.

If you don’t have drug coverage, you should join a Medicare Part D prescription drug plan, even if your drug costs are low. It is cheap insurance and there are premiums at $20 a month or less in every state. In one State there is a plan that costs only about $4 a month! Many cost $10 a month or less. Cancer and other dread diseases with high drug costs don't wait until the next Open Season to strike, so everyone should have current drug coverage "just in case." That is why it is called insurance. The very best thing about Medicare Part D is that it guarantees that you will never spend more than $3600 for drugs. The so-called “donut hole” is best understood as a guaranteed limit against financial catastrophe. Almost everyone can buy true insurance and peace of mind for under one or two hundred dollars a year.

If your income is limited (below about $15,000 a year) and your savings low you can get extra help and your Part D coverage will be almost free. Almost-free coverage even makes sense for someone with “creditable coverage” in a good retiree plan, unless you lose other benefits. Eligibility checking is simple at www.ssa.gov or a local Social Security office.

To join up you should use the prescription drug plan comparison tool at http://www.medicare.gov/ to pick the best plan(s). Use the link to Compare Medicare Prescription Drug Plans. You type in your Rx info, drug by drug, and it tells you which plans give you the best deal on annual costs. If you don't already use the Internet, find a friend, neighbor, relative, librarian, or Aging Agency person to give you help. It takes about a half hour if you have your prescription drug information handy (copies of your drug receipts from pharmacies have the key details). Or you can have the government run the computer program for you by calling 1-800-MEDICARE. You can find the least expensive plans—taking into account both premium and coverage—and pick the one that is most convenient to you.

Also consider joining a Medicare Advantage plan. Most of them give you not only drug coverage but also pay most deductibles and coinsurance for “zero premium” extra. They now include not just HMOs, but also Preferred Provider (PPO) plans and even some fee for service plans. Most of them are great insurance deals if you are willing to accept some restrictions on provider choice. If you don't know which one to pick, an easy strategy is to narrow your choice by asking your physician which plan(s) he or she participates in. One good source for finding best buys is at www.medicarenewswatch.com.

The best publication is the one everybody on Medicare gets for free, Medicare & You 2006. It is totally revised to deal with the new benefits and plans. There are also some handy summary tables at http://www.medicare.gov/ for both Medicare prescription drug and Medicare Advantage plans. But don’t try to study the details of many plans. Use the drug plan comparison tool to simplify your choice!

Join right away. If you join by December 31st, 2005, your coverage starts on January 1st. You can wait as long as May 15, 2006, but you not only lose valuable coverage but also may have a last minute “senior moment.” Don’t put it off! (You can even change your mind later, so you lose nothing by signing up now.) There are penalties for late enrollment, but the big cost is giving up insurance savings. You can join on the Internet, by calling the plan number, or at 1-800-MEDICARE.
That is it. Nothing really confusing and or hard to figure out if you use the Internet and your common sense, with a little homework. There are many more details but most seniors don’t need to focus on those. And you can always call 1-800-MEDICARE for additional details, or for help in signing "

Saturday, December 17, 2005

The Free Market Lives

Most of the time, I hold myself out to be a moderate in politics. On days when I’m somewhat more full of myself, I proclaim that I’m an Edmund Burke Conservative. But when the Busch and my more combative streaks are in full flower, I announce that I’m a poor man’s Tom Paine. Those points given, I usually take other pundits at their word about what or who they are. They are almost all hard right or left; otherwise, they couldn’t draw listeners, readers, or viewers and their audiences would be the size of mine. No offense, dear reader!

For me, Rush is a weak minded but great entertainer with an extraordinary grasp of how to milk an audience and run a mike. Too bad, but I also find him to be mean spirited. The others of his stripe on both sides of the issues get even less respect from me. As far as leading newspaper pundits are concerned, these I grant a little more honor but never forget they are whores. They’re paid to represent some sliver of the political spectrum and most deliver what they advertise.

After all this sophisticated analysis, I must admit to being naïve. I’ve taken all these people to be relatively honest in their positions. But over the course of the last year, I’ve come to realize that some of the whores do not have hearts of gold beneath those hard edged exteriors. Here I thought they meant what they said – at least a little – and all the while they’ve been two timing their pimps and regulars.

Federal money! My goodness, federal money, that ultimate aphrodisiac, has worked its magic far more effectively than I ever thought possible. Conservative pundits have been singing the virtues of a whole host of government programs, but more than a few have been paid to do it. For a few pieces of federal silver they’ll tell you the virtues of No Child Left Behind or most anything else in the Republican cupboard. Woe is Bill!

At least my faith in Arab traders was restored, a number of first class journalists in Iraq glommed onto the Iraq War supplemental budget and wrote stories in local papers proclaiming the benefits of living under American occupation. Those poor wretches were vastly underpaid and at least learned how to put bread on the table for their families.

That’s about where I stood until the past few days. I had a pretty good fix on the hookers and on which corners each belonged. All was right with the world, and I was not a complete cynic.

Above these street walkers was a class of escort services whose integrity was unassailable. Sugar daddies from both sides of the spectrum set up houses that were pure as the driven snow. South paws could be sure of the Brookings Institution, and starboard hurlers could have complete faith that the stables at The American Enterprise Institute and The Cato Institute were above reproach. But it’s not true!

The papers are full of how Bill’s been two timed. It seems that lobbyists with fists full of lucre were able to buy the services of at least one of the fellows and have him place articles extolling the virtues of the lobbyist’s clients. Go for it, capitalist baby!

Poor Bill’s now learned that beyond the money paid to these fellows, they are generally free to sell their services elsewhere providing they keep their sugar daddies informed of what they’re doing. So while they should be studying and thinking about the great imponderables, they are often typing - as Bill is this minute for free – for additional heavy metal.

Even sadder, it appears that some of people in the best houses may be subject to the siren song of federal or even private money. How awful is that?

Well at least we that what happens in Washington stays in… No, what happens in the Capital often leads to Las Vegas.

The free market lives!

Blog on!

Wild Bill

Friday, December 16, 2005

DNA Not Required

President Bush broke the law. He broke a very important law that prohibits domestic spying by Federal agents. He broke the law almost certainly with full knowledge that he was doing it; White House Counsel certainly gave an opinion that what was proposed was illegal and improper. That is scary!

Agents are permitted to spy on citizens within the country if they can convince appropriate courts that national security violations are taking place. The president signed an order directing a federal agency to carry out surveillance on activities outside the scope of the law. That is very scary!

What is most frightening to me is not what I have just written but rather that high federal officials would agree to carry out such illegal activities if the president would agree to sign off and take responsibility.

I served in the military, honorably if not spectacularly, and spent most of my adult life working for the federal government, including two times in different elements of the Executive Office of the President, The Council on Wage and Price Stability and The Office of Management and Budget.

The army drilled into us that we were never required to obey an illegal order. Indeed we were told that if we obeyed such an order, we would be guilty of whatever crime we might commit in doing what we were told. While as a civil servant I do not remember being explicitly trained that the military concept of following illegal orders was correct, I felt throughout my career that that was the case and was never disabused of the notion.

Having known of many cases where federal employees did violate this concept under pressure from superiors, I am not shocked that the National Security Agency has itself in a pickle over this. What is most amazing is that Bush signed the directive. That’s stupid!

Presidents wanting to have illegal actions taken in the past did it with a wink and a nod. When they wanted the IRS or the FBI to do things they weren’t supposed to, they just hinted. Mr. Bush has apparently signed a document authorizing on his personal authority the NSA to spy – illegally. How dumb can you be?

This may all go away. No one really wants to impeach the president for wanting to defend the nation, but, my God, this is stupid and scary.

Blog on!

Wild Bill

Thursday, December 15, 2005

Be a Blogger

Do you have opinions? Strong ones? If you share them with family and friends, what’s your reach?

Just who the hell is Rush Limbaugh? Al Franken? What gives the New York Times the right to sole possession of your thoughts? The Wall Street Journal? USA Today? Do you always agree with the fair and balanced FOX News? You mean you agree with everything Lou Dobbs says about immigration and globalization? How about that local talk show host, does he speak for you? And that lady with the local cable access show, does she always have it right?

Of course you have thoughts and Constitutional right to express them. Sure you’ve had coffee and doughnuts with the same six people for the last twelve years. They know your opinion on everything and you know what they have to say about Bush, Iraq and Social Security. But who are you influencing?

While you’re mouthing off at the Dew Drop Inn, your State Rep and Congressman are letting lobbyists tell them what’s good for you. Do you suppose that’s really in your best interests? While you’re sipping java and banging your gums with Fred and Mildred, your Congressman’s sending your tax dollars to a thousand and one places you don’t want them to go.

A year and a half ago, I decided to fight for what I thought was right. Free Blogs became available, and while I’m a technical klutz, I decided to do battle. It took a little work and more than a few errors, but now I’m a blogger. I was always a writer of letters to editors and succeeded in getting quite a few missives printed – even in some big papers. But they can’t print everything you write; they have to spread the wealth and, besides, they’re paying people to follow their lead and think for you.

After these months, dear readers, I’ve worked like a dog to influence you and to change if you think I’m wrong – if I agree with the assessment. Blogging isn’t easy. If you don’t write regularly, your readers drift away. Without an editor, you’re bound to make mistakes – lots of them – and look like an ignoramus. But over time, if you try to be reasonable and consistent, you can spread your views. How far? How influentially? It’s impossible to say. There are a few clues to guide you. Every once in a while, Google – which supports my blog for free – tallies up the number of people who have explored my site, not just landed on the blog on purpose or by accident. A month or so ago, the number of people who read my profile came in at just under 500. I’m pretty sure it’s more than that by now, but Google doesn’t hurry even when major milestones are just waiting to be met.

I also put a counter on my blog to see how many people landed on it, but that’s imperfect since, among other things, it counts my own checks – several a day – to see if people are reading. I also have a fairly substantial list of folks to whom I send selected articles, so they often read the postings without being counted. Then there folks who get my writings automatically; they’re far too technically advanced for me and leave no finger prints.

So, after all this hand wringing, how many people read this blog? I don’t know. But with all the clues above and several others, it’s probably in the range of fifty to a hundred; double that is possible but that would be miraculous. Not a lot huh? For all the work thinking about a topic for the day and committing it to electronic pulses, that doesn’t seem like much.

But I’m a cup half full kind of person. My friends and I share our views and frustrations on a wide variety of subjects, and I’m sure there is some outside fertilization as a result of our regular interactions. But my – their - collective reach and influence on topics of interest and importance to me and us is extremely limited. Besides, I like writing my thoughts. Francis Bacon was correct when he said, “Reading maketh a full man; conference a ready man and writing an exact man.” Truly, forcing one’s self to write and publish positions on matters of controversy makes one as careful, precise and exact as possible. It clears the cobwebs of the mind.

So please dear readers, think about joining me in this venture. I’m quite sure that you either agree with almost all of my positions or are unalterably opposed to the content of my blog. Either way, by blogging along with me, the level of public discourse can be improved and expanded, and, even though in only a limited manner, our influence on those who would like to make us think correctly – as they see it - will be there and they willhave to account for us.

Blogging is far easier than most people believe. Start!

Blog on!

Wild Bill

Tuesday, December 13, 2005

Goodbye Tookie

Tookie Wilson is dead – no big deal. From all that I’ve read in the past several days, he was a very bad person, and the only redeeming things to be said about him are that in prison he tried to tell young people that the outlaw way will not lead to a productive life. Perhaps his death will reinforce the lesson.

That said; I’m unalterably opposed to the death penalty. First and foremost, there is and always will be the chance that we will execute innocent people. If you believe that then you have to accept that the Tookie Wilsons of the planet – and there are more than a few of them – will have to be spared.

I don’t want to blame Governor Schwarzenegger for his call. I don’t know anything about the law in California, but capital punishment is the prescribed penalty there and only if the case in point overtly fails to meet the requirements then can sending a person to his or her death be set explicitly at the governor’s door step. I read the governor’s statement on the case, and he seems to have genuinely tried to give full consideration to the total Tookie Wilson. The governor was, however, under pressure from his conservative base and politics is always part of the process

This morning while running errands, I listened to a local right wing talk show and was appalled. Wilson’s death was treated by many his callers as an event of joy. The host parodied an old time popular song by singing “Took, Took, Tookie, Goodbye.” This barbarism was mighty callous for a person who holds himself out to be a civilized person.

It is possible, even likely, that Wilson was every bit as evil as the callers indicated, but I cannot understand why the death penalty is the answer. If innocence is possible, how can we send people to their deaths and be unable to make amends should it ever come to light that a mistake was made?

Capital punishment is certainly not a deterrent to offenses warranting the death penalty. California has had the remedy for years and still people are murdered in heinous manners. Texas has taken the lives of killers in huge numbers and still grisly murders take place there. The same can be said for my State of Virginia which has executed more than its share of killers and probably innocent men and women. In each of these jurisdictions the murder rate is significantly higher than in some other states that have abandoned the ultimate penalty.

How much greater penalty is execution than life in prison without the possibility of parole? I read the account of the Wilson death, and he got on the gurney without any sign of struggle. Most of the people facing execution do so with stout hearts – or at least resignation. Years on death row seems to have steeled them against their fate. In some cases there is probably a release; it’s over, so be it. Besides some perhaps most of them are guilty as sin and accept the need for society to seek its punishment, and most of them are not trained ethicists.

I’ve read and do not doubt that it costs far more to carry out capital punishment than to incarcerate convicted killers. Clearly, California with the longest appeals process in the country with average terms on death row of a quarter of a century spends far more than would they would by simply locking them up and throwing away the key.

In every controversial case, the family of the victims is trotted out and they claim that they will not get closure until the beast is killed. While I know that I would make the same type of statement were I the father, brother, husband or friend of someone murdered in cold blood, it should be the role of the state to seek justice in the name of all of the people – not just those who loved the victims – and not to cater to the bloodthirsty needs of those left behind. Besides, my – and their – need for revenge could possibly be misplaced; it has happened that innocent people have gone down to the savage satisfaction of those loved ones still alive. An apology and a `too bad' just don’t hack it in such circumstances.

Why then are so many people, especially those committed to the sanctity of life, filled with joy when a fellow human being is put to death?

The fault lies not exclusively with the politicians – although they owe us leadership in such circumstances – but with us all.

Blog on!

Wild Bill